Pacifier Pros and Cons.  When to use baby pacifiers and when to throw them out.

Is it time to throw away the pacifier?  Find out when to use a baby pacifier.

When babies are born one of the first things we give them are pacifiers.  Giving a pacifier to a baby can be very helpful and useful those first few days, weeks and months.  Pacifiers can be a lifesaver. You should also know the pros of using a pacifier.  The advantages stop once your baby is a few months old.  Learn pacifier pros and cons.  Reasons why you should throw away pacifiers early on.


This is a long post and I understand you may not have the time to read this now.  Instead of scrolling through why don’t I send you the cliff notes version so you can read it when it’s good for you.  (Remember how great cliff notes were?) 

Ultimate guide for pacifier pros and cons

The Pacifier Debate

Baby grabbing a pacifier. When to use a pacifier.

Any time you talk to parents about a pacifier you typically are going to get strong options.  The pacifier debate is something that has gone on for decades.  Though, there is proven reasons why the pacifier is helpful to your child and then reasons when it turns to hurt your child.

I should mention that sometimes doctors or lactation specialist recommend waiting to introduce the pacifier if you are excessively breastfeeding.  They say to wait a few weeks until the baby knows how to nurse before introducing a pacifier.  Some people feel that it can cause nipple/ breast confusion.  This is due to the fact that the nipple and pacifier are a different shape. If you are having any trouble producing milk or your child latching you should wait a few weeks before introducing a pacifier. (I did breastfeed and gave the pacifier right away. Luckily, I had no trouble.)


This post may contain affiliate links.  If you purchase through these links I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.  As an Amazon associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.  For more information please check my Disclosure Policy


The Best pacifier to use

These are rated the best pacifiers for newborns and babies.


The First Year’s Gum Drop Pacifier

Best for breastfeed babies.  These pacifiers have a scoop front to stay under babies nose.


Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier

These are made out of hard, hospital silicone.  Has a large round face so may get in the way of the baby’s nose.

WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier

Typically comes with the attached stuffed animal.

Bibs Natural Rubber Pacifier

Made of natural rubber which is supposed to mimic the feel of a breast.  It has a rounded tip as well.



Natursutten Natural Rubber Pacifier

This has a smaller, rounded nipple.  It’s one piece without a shield.



MAM Clear Orthodontic Pacifier

It helps protect your baby’s jaw as it develops. The shield has a large button to hold to help put the pacifier in and out of their mouths.  This is hard to attach to pacifier clips.


Philips Avent Orthodontic Pacifier

This has a larger nipple that can be beneficial to babies that have a tongue tie.



Playtex Binky Silicone Pacifier

This is also shaped more like mom’s nipple.  It has a short nipple that helps for those babies that gag on larger nipples.


We used the pacifier that was given to us in the hospital.  Those are the Philips Avent Pacifiers. To be honest, we didn’t try others to see what worked, that was the only we used.  After a few months old we stopped using a pacifier completely. If you continue to use a pacifier as your child gets older you may have to switch from the one you started with.


Helpful tips to make your days a bit easier. Family Routines is an online course for parents struggling with feeling guilty & stressed out by daily tasks. You’ll be able to simplify and find priorities to create easier days. Parenting advice so you can automate your house life.


Related baby articles you will also enjoy

Milk Allergy in Babies

Ways to encourage language 

Reasons not to use a sippy cup



Pacifier Accessories 


Pacifier Clips

These are easy to attach to the baby’s clothing so the pacifier doesn’t fall to the floor.


Pacifier animal

You can choose the animal of your choice to hold your baby’s pacifier.  The stuffed animals are easy for babies to hold onto.


Pacifier holders

These are little cases that hold the pacifier so it’s easy to throw into the diaper bag.  They remind me of when I used to have a retainer.



Latex vs. silicone:

You’ll probably want to pick a silicone pacifier because it’s sturdier, longer-lasting and doesn’t retain odors.  It is also top-rack dishwasher safe.

Latex is softer and more flexible but wears out sooner. The babies’ teeth can also bite through it.


TIP: After you choose a pacifier or your baby chooses one they like I’d advise having at least 4 in the house.  This will help you to not run around the house when you want to use the pacifier.  If you have a crying baby you want something close that will help soothe them.  Also, if your child gets used to a specific kind and then loses it they won’t be happy with a new pacifier.  You can keep one downstairs, one in the bedroom, one in the diaper bag and one in the living room.


Pacifier Pros

  • Soothe babies when not hungry

Your baby might be fussy, or uncomfortable but that doesn’t mean hungry.  Using a pacifier can help see if your baby wants to suck or if they are actually hungry.

  • For preemies, it helps with learning early sucking patterns

Preemie sucking patterns are not always present early on.  Using a pacifier can help them develop this skill.

  • Easy and convenient

Pacifiers are small and you can throw into any bag or diaper bag.  You can bring 2 or 3 with you when you go out.

  • Helps with travel 

If you are traveling to see family or on a little vacation, the use of a pacifier on a plane can help.  As they use a pacifier it can help their ears pop so they don’t feel pain and cry.

  • Reduces thumb or finger sucking

It’s easier to break the habit of using a pacifier than it is thumb sucking.  You can’t take away their thumbs.

  • It can reduce the risk of SIDS

SIDS stands for Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.  By sucking on a pacifier at night during the early months, it prevents babies from falling into a deep, heavy sleep and then can help reduce the risk of SIDS. This is not something that is proven but has a strong correlation. ( Having a strong correlation was reason enough for me to use it when my child was an infant.  Anything I could do to prevent SIDS I would.)


Since babies are born with a need to suck it’s good to use a pacifier early on.  It can be a great thing. When your home with your new little baby and they are fussing, but you just feed them, using a pacifier can be a lifesaver.  You are trying to get your baby to sleep a little bit more, using the pacifier comes to the rescue.  All the pros of using a pacifier are for infants and babies under 6 months.  After a few months, these benefits are no longer there. At 6-8 months if you are still using the pacifier, the best plan is to only use the pacifier in bed for naptime or bedtime.  Then it will be associated with sleep instead of using it all day.


Pacifier Cons with prolonged use after age 1 

A small child trying to reach for a pacifier. Discussing pros and cons of pacifier use.

  • Increase the chance of ear infections
  • Increase dental problems

The most common problems are misaligned teeth and changes in the roof of the mouth.  It’s common that children develop a gap between the top and bottom teeth.


Related Toddler Reading

Reasons why you should not use a toddler sippy cup 


  • Delayed language development.

When a toddler has a binky in their mouths during the day they are less likely to make sounds and words to communicate.  It can affect socialize time.

  • Becomes dependant on using a binky

Your baby may want to use the pacifier all the time.  They want the pacifier when they are moving around, playing and sleeping.  When your child is sleeping they wake up every time the pacifier falls out of their mouth.  You then have to get up and place the pacifier back in their mouth to go back to sleep.  You are not sleeping and neither is your baby.  Getting up every half hour is not helping anyone.


This is a long post and I understand you may not have the time to read this now.  Instead of scrolling through why don’t I send you the cliff notes version so you can read it when it’s good for you.  (Remember how great cliff notes were?) 

8 Tips for weaning your child off the pacifier

The earlier you start, the easier it will be.  As your child gets older they get more attached and habits form.  If you get rid of the pacifier before their 1st birthday, you won’t experience the problems listed above.  You will also have an easier time getting rid of the pacifier at 9 months then you will at 2 1/12.


Whichever method you choose for your family, be consistent. Don’t go back on what you said or what you started to put into effect.  Children learn very quickly how they can get what they want.

  • Cold Turkey

Pacifier weaning cold turkey is when you get rid of everyone in the house and are no longer giving them to your child.  It’s not used during the day or night, it’s no longer used.

  • Family and caregivers on the same page

When you make the decision to start to wean or remove the pacifier make sure everyone is on the same page.  If Dad comes home from work and gives the pacifier or Grandma comes over and gives it to them then the child knows that they can still have the pacifier.  You don’t want to send mixed signals to your child.  This will make it that much harder to reach the goal of no pacifier.

  • Something new for comfort

You could get a new stuffed animal or new blanket that they would have in bed.  If your child is past 1 years old, they can have a blanket or stuffed animal in bed.

  • Slow Weaning

Hopefully, your baby is only using the pacifier in bed for naptime or bedtime.  If you haven’t started that yet, start now.  Slowly start to only give the pacifier for bedtime.  Don’t give them when you are out of the house or when the baby is crawling/walking around.

These other strategies are all part of slow weaning.

  • Give them away

You can tell your child you are giving them away to other babies that need it.  For this, you can do a few different things. If you are close to Easter of Christmas they can leave all their binkies for the Easter Bunny or Santa.  Some kids like the idea of leaving the binkies for the Easter Bunny or Santa.  Doing this also allows the child to be in some control.

Your child can also give them away to other babies in the family.  This only works if the baby doesn’t live in the same house.  It doesn’t work with a sibling cause then the child still sees their binky in the house and they want it.

  • Binky Fairy

This is along the lines of the Easter Bunny or Santa but it’s a new magical being just for binkies and pacifiers. You can start talking about the binky fairy and that there only job is to come to get pacifiers when you are too old for them.  If you leave the pacifiers the Binky Fairy will leave a special gift in return.

  • Set a Countdown

You can have a chart or calendar up and pick a day a few weeks away.  Mark the date with stickers.  Prepare your child that they will get rid of the pacifier by that date.

  • Change the desire they get

Many parents have had success with cutting tips off the pacifier.  This then changes the benefit they get.


When to stop Pacifier use with your little one?

The younger your child is the easier it will be to get rid of the pacifier.  Once your child is past 9-11 months they develop an attachment to a binky.  They have an emotional attachment and will be much harder to get rid of it.  Once you have a toddler they will protest and possibly fight giving up a pacifier.  That is why you always hear parents ask “How do I get my child to stop using a binky?”  This is a common question among parents.


Using a pacifier in the first few months of your baby’s life can be really helpful.  Babies have a need to suck and using a pacifier can help soothe them.  If you stop using the pacifier early on you will avoid any of the problems associated with pacifier use.


I breastfeed and used a pacifier with my kids.  I stopped using the pacifier by 7 months.  At that point, it wasn’t hard to get rid of the pacifier.  When my kids turned 1 they got a stuffed animal to sleep with.


I would love to hear which strategy worked best for your little one.  Comment below and share.


Pacifier Pros and Cons to help know when to use them and when to throw them out.

No idea how to entertain your toddler? Looking for things to do at home?  Get dozens of fun learning activities for your toddler here.  Click below to get your Toddler Enrichment Ebook today. 

Toddler Enrichment Ebook. Help your child learn while maintaining your sanity.


Wait! Don’t leave without grabbing the Free Guide to know how to get rid of the pacifier (PDF). 

Ultimate guide for pacifier pros and cons



PS. If you found this post on Pacifier Pros and Cons helpful, be sure to PIN ME to your favorite baby board on Pinterest.

Baby grabbing a pacifier. Learn when to throw out the pacifier



  1. My pediatrician told us it is best to try and take the pacifier away before 6 months because it has not become a habit for them yet. When you do it later, it because harder because they know it is missing.

    Another trick for getting rid of it is cutting a hole in the nipple of the pacifier so the child no longer gets the desired effect from sucking on it.

    1. Yes, I agree it’s best to get rid of the pacifier early it makes it easier. I wrote that tip above in one way to get rid of pacifiers. Cutting the tip off has worked for many parents. Like you, we got rid of the pacifiers early before there was a big attachment. Stopping using a pacifier early is a big benefit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *